8 – The AP Chemistry Reforms

Eric Nelson 1,118 Comments

The new 2013 AP Chemistry Framework and its 2014 Exam asked students to solve problems by de-emphasizing factual recall/memorization and practicing inquiry/reasoning. Recent studies in cognitive science have proven that those strategies simply do not work for students in first-year college-level science courses. The result was a 2014 AP Chemistry Exam in which 73% of students received a 3 or below.  Directing students to use problem-solving methods that science has proven do not work was profoundly unfair to students and their instructors.

The College Board (CB) is evaluating the 2013/14 changes to the AP Chemistry program over the next several months. Below are findings from cognitive research that during that review hopefully they may consider.

The 2013 AP Chemistry reforms focused on 4 areas:

  1. Limiting content but improving understanding.
  2. Decreasing reliance on memorization/recall.
  3. Increasing reliance on reasoning and guided inquiry in learning, and
  4. Applying knowledge to new contexts.

Over the past 4 years, researchers in cognitive science (the field of how the brain works and how it learns) have agreed on recommendations for how students can best be taught to solve problems in math and the physical sciences. Unfortunately, in 3 of the 4 areas above, the AP Curriculum Framework gives direction that is the opposite of the recommendations of cognitive science.

Going forward, to be in agreement with science’s understanding of how the brain solves problems, the AP Chemistry Framework will need to change. Let’s examine the “reforms” above one at a time.

1.  The new AP framework (p. 8) calls for “balancing breadth of content coverage with depth of understanding.” Cognitive research supports this finding. During initial learning, the primary goal is to increase knowledge in a student’s long-term memory (LTM). To build LTM requires repeated practice spaced over multiple days. If students are asked to learn too much new information at once, they tend to “cram” and learning does not “stick.” Limiting, mastering, and focusing on the connotations of new content is change consistent with cognitive science.

2.  The new AP framework (p. 8) advocates that students “spend less time on factual recall” and disparages “mere rote recall” (p. 16). A “Course Planning and Pacing Guide” on the CB website states: “The framework emphasizes moving students beyond formulaic algorithms and focusing instead on conceptual reasoning.”

Cognitive scientists are in agreement that students must devote years to moving facts and problem solving algorithms into memory before that can “reason conceptually” in the way experts in science can do.  In pre-graduate-school math and science, students must be able to recall, quickly and automatically from LTM, nearly all of the facts and algorithms needed to solve a problem. This is because working memory (WM), where the brain solves problems, can “conceptually reason” with essentially all information recallable from LTM, but with very limited amounts of non-memorized knowledge.

At this link, on pages 8-12, leading cognitive scientists document these findings.

 Putting Students on the Path to Learning: The Case for Fully Guided Instruction, at:

https://www.aft.org/sites/default/files/Clark.pdf

As of  2014, the strengths and weaknesses of working memory, among scientists who study how the brain solves problems, are undisputed facts. In disparaging factual recall, the College Board was advising students based on outdated understandings no longer in agreement with what experts in how the brain works say is true.

In the book Make It Stick and articles by Daniel Willingham (see the Read Recs tab above), researchers in cognition advise instructors on ways to help students gradually construct both memory and understanding.

For AP teachers, the message from cognitive science is that memorization is even more important than we thought.

3.  The AP framework advises instructors and students to “spend more time on inquiry-based learning.” The website’s “AP Science Inquiry Statement” (4/21/11) advocates both “guided” and “open inquiry” using “student-designed procedures.”  The first three pages of the Clark summary document the overwhelming evidence that for the learning of new content to be efficient, students need to be clearly informed of what experts over centuries have found to be true.  These studies show that “Open inquiry,” in which students’ formulate their own questions and study procedures, is particularly inefficient.

As Clark, et. al. note (page 7):

 “Researchers…   tested whether those who had learned through discovery were better able to transfer their learning to new contexts…. Direct instruction involving considerable guidance … resulted in vastly more learning than discovery.”

That said, as the Clark authors note, guided inquiry can be a way to practice the application of newly acquired knowledge. In addition, inquiry can “prepare students for learning,” spark curiosity, and foster essential motivation. To the extent that explaining and committing content to memory can be done during study time, cognitive studies indicate that inquiry guided by instructors can be a good use of class time.

Again, these research conclusions are likely not surprising to AP instructors.

4.  The CB staff explanation of the 2014 Exam Results, posted on the AP Chemistry bulletin board on June 16, states (p. 6):

 The redesigned AP Chemistry Exam questions each require students to go beyond factual recall and calculations …, demonstrate a clear understanding … and apply that understanding to new scenarios, just as they will be required to do in science majors and careers.

How well students can transfer  facts and procedures to new situations has been found to be dependent on the number of elements of a situation that are familiar in memory. That expert knowledge takes years of study to acquire (Clark, p. 9-11). “Far transfer” is a key skill for professionals, but to find employment in chemistry generally requires at least 30 college chemistry credits, not 8. If we push students to use strategies which do not fit what their brain at that point can do, many aspiring science students will be handicapped, discouraged, and frustrated (Clark, p. 8).

Additional evidence that the type of instruction now being advocated by the CB does not work is provided by the 2014 AP exam results. The AP framework (page 3) states that questions are reviewed to ensure they are “fair and that there is an appropriate spread of difficulty.” That’s the right goal. However, on the 2014 free response questions, the score average ranged from 11% to 42%, with a median 33%. Is that “an appropriate spread of difficulty?”

The percentage of students scoring 4 or 5 was 40.4% in 2013 but  26.7% in 2014:  73% this year were given scores of 3 or below. Do the 2014 scores, for an academically select group with special interest in chemistry, indicate a fair test of what students should be able to do?

NSF data show that the percentage of U. S. college graduates who received bachelor’s degrees in chemistry fell from 1.61% in 1969 to 1.07% in 1990 to 0.74% in 2010. That’s a 54% decline since 1969, a serious concern for our nation. Will the 2014 AP results encourage more students to major in chemistry?

Five years ago, when CB leaders first proposed these reforms, many educational philosophies proposed that students could be spared the hard work of memorization if they instead learned reasoning skills. Those proposals were well-intended, but science is about what is true.  Those who study the brain scientifically have proven that those hopes were wishful thinking. As a result of new measurements of working memory, many past learning theories are being re-examined.

Cognitive science says that students can learn to solve problems by inquiry the way an expert can, but it requires constructing the memory of a scientist, which takes many years of effort.

In designing the new framework and exam, the CB cited the expectations of college professors — who are experts in chemistry. When shown the new data from cognitive science, it is likely that those professors will say, “Respect the domain expertise of those who study the brain. Don’t deny the science.”

Some without credentials in cognitive science continue to advocate for their philosophies, but in making decisions that decide the welfare of young people, the findings of experts in a scientific domain must prevail over beliefs.

For our best high school students, seeking to learn chemistry, willing to take a demanding AP course,  the CB has given 73% of those students a 3 or below – what the world calls a C or below – because students could not learn in one course what science has proven takes years of intense study. That is profoundly unfair.

The CB is using its Curriculum Framework and  exam to pressure teachers to teach in a certain way.   The methods the CB is pressuring teachers to use cognitive science has found do not work.

But the cognitive science findings are recent, and the CB deserves the opportunity to make this right.  An easy way to do so is for the CB to reverse its decision to tell teachers how to teach.

Until 2014,  the College Board provided a fair test of the range of problems that students can be taught to solve in a first course in college chemistry. That rigorous external standard motivated instructors to find ways to improve achievement.  To return to providing such a test would continue the College Board’s substantial heritage of service to students, instructors, and the nation.

 # # # # #

 

1,118 Responses

  1. MaXJanny January 15, 2026 / 1:02 pm

    Здравствуйте дорогие друзья! В этой статье я расскажу про обработку днища. По моему мнению понял: нет времени разбираться — могу рекомендовать мастера: шумоизоляция дверей авто . Суть в том, что: крыша — это источник низкочастотного гула. Например включаешь музыку — слышишь дребезг? Значит металл не обработан. Можно поставить виброизоляцию с высоким КМП, сверху — акустический материал. Вот потому что это работает. Что в итоге: двери станут как в премиуме.

    Reply
  2. Krovlyawet January 15, 2026 / 1:13 pm

    Приветствую! Очень актуальная тема — ремонт кровли промышленного здания. Нет времени искать — могу рекомендовать проверенную компанию: установка мембранной кровли. Как правило большие площади — нуждаются в профессионалах. Короче, сложная конфигурация — то есть важен опыт бригады. Мы используем профессиональное оборудование. Вот потому что один из самых эффективных способов. Что в итоге: крыша сдаётся с гарантией.

    Reply
  3. Krovlyawet January 17, 2026 / 11:58 am

    Приветствую! Разберём самые актуальные — кровля для склада. Дело в том, что: складские помещения — это огромные площади. Ищешь подрядчика — вот проверенные: монтаж мембранной кровли. Лично я убедился, что для складов — полимеры идеальны. Допустим крыша 5000 квадратов — так вот мембрану укладывают механическим способом. Самый передовой материал — армированные ПВХ мембраны. Что в итоге: высокоэффективный инструмент — склад защищён.

    Reply
  4. MaXJanny January 17, 2026 / 11:58 am

    Приветствую! Очень актуальная тема — гул в салоне. Суть в том, что нет времени ковыряться — могу рекомендовать ребятам тут: шумоизоляция автомобилей. В большинстве случаев главная причина шума от колёс — это дребезг панелей в нишах. Что это значит? Допустим, на вираже характер шума плывёт — соответственно вибрирует капот. Что делать для самостоятельной работы: снятие локера, качественное обезжиривание, укладка вибропоглотителя с тщательным прижимом. Резюмируем: это работает — ощутимая тишина.

    Reply
  323. elektrokarnizi dlya shtor_unpl February 7, 2026 / 2:00 pm

    электрокарнизы для штор купить [url=https://elektrokarnizy-dlya-shtor1.ru/]электрокарнизы для штор купить[/url] .

    Reply
  494. AndreTib February 12, 2026 / 9:14 pm

    After travel, cornbread edibles has been leisurely to pack and store. The bottle seals tensely, and there’s no leakage. The minimalist manipulation looks able and guarded, which makes it comfortable to carry around.

    Reply
  559. vnedrenie 1s_nqsa February 15, 2026 / 11:20 am

    внедрение 1с 8 3 [url=https://1s-vnedrenie.ru/]внедрение 1с 8 3[/url] .

    Reply
  571. Trezvii vibor_exsa February 15, 2026 / 4:52 pm

    trezviy-vibor [url=https://www.facewoman.ru/vyvod-iz-zapoya-v-donecke.html]https://www.facewoman.ru/vyvod-iz-zapoya-v-donecke.html[/url] .

    Reply
  572. mostbet_rcpi February 15, 2026 / 4:54 pm

    mostbet смотреть матчи [url=https://www.mostbet20394.help]https://www.mostbet20394.help[/url]

    Reply
  592. 1win_acml February 16, 2026 / 4:57 am

    1win как зарегистрироваться [url=http://1win23576.help]http://1win23576.help[/url]

    Reply
  597. mostbet_ppMt February 16, 2026 / 7:50 am

    как вывести на каспи с mostbet [url=https://www.mostbet93746.help]https://www.mostbet93746.help[/url]

    Reply
  602. 1win_kiei February 16, 2026 / 9:48 am

    1win бонус на авиатор [url=1win70163.help]1win бонус на авиатор[/url]

    Reply
  621. WilliamDrace February 16, 2026 / 9:28 pm

    The mood delta 9 gummies arrived admirably protected, with secure wrapping and clear instructions included. The whole kit was organized neatly advantageous the box, which made the unboxing happening satisfying and polished.

    Reply
  627. Rekonstrykciya zdanii_hsKa February 17, 2026 / 3:01 am

    усиление несущих конструкций [url=https://rekonstrukcziya-zdanij.ru/]rekonstrukcziya-zdanij.ru[/url] .

    Reply
  634. Rekonstrykciya zdanii_nkMl February 17, 2026 / 6:11 am

    преимущества капитальной реконструкции здания [url=https://rekonstrukcziya-zdanij-2.ru/]преимущества капитальной реконструкции здания[/url] .

    Reply
  666. pinup_qrPn February 17, 2026 / 7:16 pm

    pin-up ro‘yxatdan o‘tishsiz demo [url=pinup15293.help]pin-up ro‘yxatdan o‘tishsiz demo[/url]

    Reply
  716. Ismaelaerob February 19, 2026 / 12:54 am

    Wow that was strange. I just wrote an very long comment but after I clicked submit my comment didn’t show up. Grrrr… well I’m not writing all that over again. Anyways, just wanted to say fantastic blog!
    byueuropaviagraonline

    Reply
  813. Kennethtig February 20, 2026 / 10:42 pm

    sparkdex SparkDex is redefining decentralized trading with speed, security, and real earning potential. On spark dex, you keep full control of your assets while enjoying fast swaps and low fees. Powered by sparkdex ai, the platform delivers smarter insights and optimized performance for confident decision-making. Trade, earn from liquidity, and grow your crypto portfolio with sparkdex — the future of DeFi starts here.

    Reply
  815. Krovlyawet February 21, 2026 / 1:00 am

    Здравствуйте дорогие друзья! Разберём самые актуальные — кому доверить крышу. Здесь такой момент: рынок полон непрофессионалов. Лично проверял: https://montazh-membrannoj-krovli-spb.ru. Как правило качество зависит от бригады. Короче сварка швов — тут нужен профессионализм. Общие рекомендации: не гнаться за дешевизной. Вот и соответственно надёжная бригада — залог долговечной кровли. Резюмируем: это работает получить качество.

    Reply
  841. Spinania February 22, 2026 / 9:36 am

    Jesli chcesz wyprobowac kasyno bez ryzyka, Spinania dla kazdego nowego gracza.

    Reply
  844. Krovlyawet February 22, 2026 / 12:51 pm

    Привет всем! Стоит заранее разобрать — укладка поверх старого покрытия. Дело в том, что: иногда не нужно снимать старое. Хочешь сэкономить — могу рекомендовать: установка мембранной кровли. Что это значит: проверяют основание, когда нет вздутий — укладывают мембрану поверх. В общем старый рубероид крепкий — соответственно работы быстрее. Мы используем подкладочный слой. Резюмируем: удаётся достигать классных результатов — без лишних расходов.

    Reply
  870. auto 742 February 24, 2026 / 8:11 am

    A convenient car catalog https://auto.ae/catalog brands, models, specifications, and current prices. Compare engines, fuel consumption, trim levels, and equipment to find the car that meets your needs.

    Reply
  880. maxispin_u_fwOl March 1, 2026 / 11:26 pm

    For those seeking an exceptional online gaming experience, us.com](https://maxispin.us.com/) stands out as a premier destination. At Maxispin Casino, players can enjoy a vast array of pokies, table games, and other thrilling options, all accessible in both demo and real-money modes. The casino offers attractive bonuses, including free spins and a generous welcome offer, along with cashback promotions and engaging tournaments. To ensure a seamless experience, Maxispin provides various payment methods, efficient withdrawal processes, and reliable customer support through live chat. Security is a top priority, with robust safety measures and a strong focus on responsible gambling tools. Players can easily navigate the site, with detailed guides on account creation, verification, and payment methods. Whether you’re interested in high RTP slots, hold and win pokies, or the latest slot releases, Maxispin Casino delivers a user-friendly and secure platform. Explore their terms and conditions, read reviews, and discover why many consider Maxispin a legitimate and trustworthy choice in Australia.
    Utilizing AI technology, MaxiSpin.us.com makes sure your content excels in the competitive market.

    **Features of MaxiSpin.us.com**
    The platform also features a built-in editor, allowing users to make immediate adjustments for the best outcomes.

    **Benefits of Using MaxiSpin.us.com**
    The platform is also cost-effective, providing high-quality content at a fraction of the cost of traditional methods.

    Reply
  881. maxispin_u_jqOl March 2, 2026 / 8:17 am

    For those seeking an exceptional online gaming experience, us.com](https://maxispin.us.com/) stands out as a premier destination. At Maxispin Casino, players can enjoy a vast array of pokies, table games, and other thrilling options, all accessible in both demo and real-money modes. The casino offers attractive bonuses, including free spins and a generous welcome offer, along with cashback promotions and engaging tournaments. To ensure a seamless experience, Maxispin provides various payment methods, efficient withdrawal processes, and reliable customer support through live chat. Security is a top priority, with robust safety measures and a strong focus on responsible gambling tools. Players can easily navigate the site, with detailed guides on account creation, verification, and payment methods. Whether you’re interested in high RTP slots, hold and win pokies, or the latest slot releases, Maxispin Casino delivers a user-friendly and secure platform. Explore their terms and conditions, read reviews, and discover why many consider Maxispin a legitimate and trustworthy choice in Australia.
    With a focus on efficiency, MaxiSpin.us.com helps users produce high-quality articles, blog posts, and marketing materials quickly.

    **Features of MaxiSpin.us.com**
    Users can input their requirements and receive tailored content in minutes.

    **Benefits of Using MaxiSpin.us.com**
    This conservation of time and resources allows businesses to concentrate on other vital areas of their operations.

    Reply
  933. maxispin_a_mrMa March 5, 2026 / 10:51 pm

    Discover the thrill of real-money live casino action at Maxispin casino bonus, where you can enjoy live dealers, top software providers, and exclusive promotions.
    Maxispin-au.com also emphasizes responsible usage and fair play across its services.

    Reply
  955. realistic microblading Melbourne March 6, 2026 / 3:35 pm

    About Premium eyebrow microblading at Face Figurati

    Good Day Girls,
    Only if you really think about Microblading eyebrows by certified artist
    Olha Po?! We have detailed information about
    realistic microblading Melbourne
    Microblading your eyebrows courtesy of certified artist Olha Po has become the
    top ask at the Cosmetic Tattoo Studio in Melbourne
    — and it’s easy to see why.

    If you’ve ever attempted makeup touch-ups while rushing, balancing on Collins Street, you’ll get what
    makes a hassle-free solution sound so good.

    I’ve been tattooing brows here in Melbourne for nearly a decade,
    and trust me — starting the day with brows that sit in the right place has
    a confidence all its own.

    Whether you’re battling oily skin, patchy growth, outdated pigment, or just
    uneven eyebrows, I want this guide to feel like catching up over coffee with me — honest.

    Wander on over, grab a cuppa, and let’s look at just how microblading works, what you
    can look forward to in the finish, and what
    you need to keep in mind before starting your journey.

    visit our site Microblading eyebrows by certified artist Olha Po
    please click https://azbongda.com/index.php/Realistic_Microblading_Melbourne_In_2026 for Sign up
    for a free consultation now!

    Our’s Tags: Feather-light microblading strokes Melbourne, realistic
    microblading Melbourne, Professional microblading Melbourne by Olha Po, https://rukorma.ru/natural-microblading-results-face-figurati-2026

    Reply
  1013. melbetweb_ntKt March 7, 2026 / 11:30 pm

    slots games [url=https://melbetweb.ru/]slots games[/url] .

    Reply
  1092. биржа таргетинг March 9, 2026 / 9:58 pm

    Здравия Желаю,
    Коллеги.

    Сегодня я бы хотел рассказать больше
    про сео.
    Я уверен Вы искали снова про биржа таргетинг!

    Значит эта наиболее актуальная информация про geo будет
    для сейчас сто процентов будет
    полезной.

    Мы предлагаем больше полезностей про crypto а также
    про веб трафик сайт, возможно и
    про удаленка?

    На нашем сайте больше про крипто,

    Качественные ссылки! Проверенные
    обратные ссылки проверенные опытом!

    НАШ SEO WEBSITE – биржа реклам: https://t.me/seovtop/239 – 2025 биржа трафика

    Только, если Вы реально искали информацию про работа биржа,
    а также про биржа работа,
    ты вы найдете самую свежую и актуальную информацию про таргет биржа или возможно
    хотите купить ссылки.

    Вы найдете много предложений для веб реклама – а именно про веб трафик сайт и про
    таргетинг реклама.
    Входите с нами в контакт на нашем
    сайте и вы наверняка найдете популярную и самую актуальную информацию от
    экспертов по поводу следующих тем касающихся
    нижеперечисленных ключевых слов, а именно:

    1. биржа таргетинг;
    2. удаленка
    3. Про таргетинг реклама;
    4. работа биржа;
    5. Web coin

    Наши Теги: биржа рафика, биржа крипто, трафик сайт,
    работа биржа, крипто.

    Доброго Вам Дня! https://t.me/seovtop/260

    Reply

Leave a Reply to sms activate_eisn Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *